Christianity and Slavery in the United States and Saint-Domingue (“Haiti”) Revisited!
Contrary to the traditional belief and standard scholarship, it is not historically true that Christianity was forced upon the entire enslaved population in the United States and in the Caribbean, especially in Saint-Domingue (“Haiti”). Many of the slaves voluntarily embraced Christianity not as a new faith, but as a continuity of the African Christianity that had existed on the African Continent even before the transatlantic slave trade and the mass African immigration to the Americas.
The process of religious syncretism between Christianity—both Protestant and Catholic expressions—and West African religion, for example, was not a difficult process for many of the slaves because of their familiarity with African Christianity. In fact, various recent studies have shown the irrefutable evidence of the rich religious diversity of the Africans who had been dragged to the United States and Saint-Domingue. They were pious muslins, animists (practitioners of African traditional religion, such as African Vodoun or Dahomean religions), and Christians. It was not in the so-called New World that the Africans encountered Christianity—both Protestant and Catholic forms—for the first time. Both Christianity and Islam were already syncretized on the African soil through the lens of African animism before European colonization and transatlantic slave trade.
On the other hand, it should be acknowledged that colonial Christianity and colonial Christian catechism were used as tools to support slavery, pacify the enslaved population, maintain white supremacy, and keep the enslaved population under direct submission. In fact, colonial Christianity was one of the most powerful engines that helped to maintain the institution of slavery both in the United States and the Caribbean and Latin American regions. Paradoxically, biblical Christian teaching on the shared humanity of all people, both the master and the slave, both the colonized and the colonizer, as well as the undisputable equality and dignity of all people, was the most strategic rhetoric employed both by abolitionists (moralists and Christian abolitionists) and abolitionist movements to end slavery in the slave-holding societies in the Americas.
Why did then the African slaves in the United States embrace Protestant Christianity and the enslaved African population at Saint-Domingue adopt Catholic Christianity?
The answer is simple. Historically, Protestant Christianity was the dominant religious expression in colonial America because the British empire was affiliated with Protestantism. By contrast, Catholic Christianity was the dominant faith of the French empire and thus influenced the religious environment in the French colonies of Saint-Domingue, Martinique, Guadeloupe, Dominica, St. Lucia, Grenada, Tobago, etc.
During the colonial period, African slaves in the American society developed their own religious system and distinctive expression of Protestant Christianity, best articulated in the nature and structure of The Black Church, and the continuous practice of African traditional religion in their midst. The first Black Protestant denomination, the African Methodist Episcopal (AME) Church, founded in 1816 by Richard Allen, bears considerable imprint of West African traditional religion and culture. Also, other Black Protestant denominations such as the African Methodist Episcopal Zion (AME Zion) Church, founded in 1821, and the Christian Methodist Episcopal (CME) Church, founded in 1870, have been also largely influenced by West African religious culture and tradition. It should be noted that Bishop Allen sent Black missionary delegates to Haiti, and in fact, the first Protestant church in Haiti was founded by African American missionaries.
Further, we can trace the origin of Black Catholicism to the French colonies in the United States, such as the state of Louisiana. (As a side note: It should be noted that French colonies [“New France”/ “Nouvelle-France”) in North America began in the early seventeenth century. One should remember that the Africans were already Catholic converts before the mass immigration to the United States. French settlers founded what is known today as Quebec in 1608. By 1682, the second-half of the seventeenth century, the French Empire expanded all the way down to the Gulf of Mexico and the Eastern region of Canada.)
In the same line of thought, African slaves at Saint-Domingue-Haiti also developed their own distinctive religious system expressed through Haitian Vodou and Haitian Catholicism. It should be noted that there were four religious systems that developed side-by-side in colonial Haiti and underwent New world innovation and creativity: the Dahomean religion best expressed through Vodou, Roman Catholicism, Islam, and eventually Protestant Christianity as early as (officially) in 1816—that is, only 12 years after the birth of the nation of Haiti. Historically speaking, some of these religious traditions have not enjoyed/ do not have enjoy the same religious freedom and rights in the Haitian society. For example, in contemporary Haitian society, Protestant Christianity is leading the way among those committed to religion.
In closing, I should also point out that Protestantism Christianity did not begin in Haiti in 1816. Protestantism already existed during the colonial period in Saint-Domingue. Few scholars of religion explored the adventurous life of the French naval officer François Levasseur, a Huguenot. The Huguenots, a dominant religious minority, were expelled from the overwhelming Catholic France. They were French Protestants in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries and committed faithfully to the teaching and theology of the French Protestant Reformer and theologian Jean Calvin. On October 16, 1865, King Louis XIV or the “Sun King” (“Le Roi Soleil”) revoked the Edict of Nantes and characterized the Protestantism of the Huguenots as a heretical faith. The Huguenots were given the choice to renounce Protestantism and join the Catholic Church. They suffered great religious persecution even to the point of death in France.
Levasseur’s tremendous work marked the beginning of French colonization in Saint-Domingue. It is observed that Levasseur solicited support from fifty fellow Protestant Christians to drive out English settlers and explorers from the island of Tortuga, Haiti. Some would have argued that that he was the first governor of Saint-Domingue, and in 1640, he established his own government there. Interestingly, on November 2, 1641, governor Levasseur signed a treaty with Chevalier Philippe de Longvilliers de Poincy, the general who represented the King of France in the Caribbean islands, stated “Les religions catholique et protestante seraient sur le pied d’égalité” (“The Catholic and Protestant religions would be on equal footing”). The referenced article somewhat exceeded the provisions of the Edict of Nantes. However, Levasseur did not honor the terms of the treaty. Some have said that he was a violent and authoritarian leader. As governor of Saint-Domingue, he prevented Catholic practitioners to exercise their own religious freedom and rights. Some have noted that he even expelled out of the island his own Protestant minister. He was murdered in 1652, and it is believed that two of his closest friends were responsible for it.
**I am indebted to my friend’s clarity, the well-regarded Haitian sociologist of religion Lewis A. Clorméus on the final paragraph on Levasseur. Lewis published a recent essay on the subject matter.